The Radoff-JEC Group Sends Open Letter to Seer, Inc. Unconflicted Independent Directors Meeta Gulyani and Nicolas Roelofs
Raises Concerns About the Board’s Continued Deference to Chair and CEO Dr.
Highlights Recently Filed Stockholder Lawsuit Against Seer and its Board Members, Which Alleges the Board Breached its Fiduciary Duties in Connection with the Adoption of the NOL Poison Pill
Calls on the Board to Immediately Announce a Sale Process to Avoid Further Value Destruction Under
***
Attn: Meeta Gulyani and
Dear Ms. Gulyani and
As one of the largest stockholders of
The dismal operating results under the leadership of
If 2026 goes according to the Board-approved operating plan, Seer will have spent four years and burned approximately
Unsurprisingly, Seer’s shares fell over 17% in response to the Company’s earnings and guidance.3 Seer’s shares continue to trade at a massive discount to its net cash balance –
Rather than hold Board Chair and CEO
It is notable that during 2025,
Since you are both relatively new to Seer, we want to ensure you are aware of the following:
-
In 2020, just prior to Seer’s initial public offering, Seer spun out
PrognomIQ, Inc. (“PrognomIQ”).8 Seer continues to own approximately 20% of PrognomIQ, andDr. Farokhzad is the Board Chair at PrognomIQ (and presumably a shareholder personally).9Mr. Ro , a Seer Board member, is also a PrognomIQ Board member, and Mr. Ro’s firm,Catalio Capital Management , invested in PrognomIQ.10 This interconnection is unusual. It is also highly concerning that Seer recently led an investment round at PrognomIQ and, that since Seer’s IPO, PrognomIQ is Seer’s largest source of revenue.11 Given this background, we believe this investment was highly questionable, as are the transactions between the companies.
-
In
February 2021 , shortly after Seer completed its IPO,Dr. Farokhzad reported selling more than 1 million shares of Seer at$64.15 per share, netting a profit of nearly$100 million .12 Subsequent to Dr. Farokhzad’s sales, Seer’s shares have declined over 97%.13
-
In 2022, while employed by Seer as Board Chair and CEO and while being paid
$6.7 million for those services,Dr. Farokhzad co-founded and served as executive chair ofDynamics Special Purpose Corp , a special purpose acquisition company (“SPAC”) that combined with Senti BioSciences, Inc. Your fellow Seer directors,Dr. Langer ,Mr. Nishar andMr. McGuire , were involved in various roles and seemingly profited from this endeavor as well. To date, shares of Dr. Farokhzad’s SPAC have declined 99.1%.14
-
Dr. Farokhzad co-founded BIND Therapeutics (“BIND”) withDr. Langer .Dr. Farokhzad notes in his Seer biography that BIND was acquired by Pfizer Inc. (“Pfizer”). That is true, butDr. Farokhzad omits from his biography that the sale to Pfizer was consummated in a bankruptcy court auction.15
-
In its approximately five years as a public company, Seer has had six director resignations. That large number of director resignations is highly unusual and points to deep-seated, systemic governance issues at Seer. We believe that if you were to review the biographies of the directors who have resigned from Seer’s Board, you would conclude that impressive, independent businesspeople have consistently resigned while
Dr. Farokhzad and his longtime friends have stayed.
In summary, the failures at Seer and its 97% share price decline are consistent with Dr. Farokhzad’s track record across multiple companies. After effectively cashing out of Seer five years ago,
We are counting on you to understand that your fiduciary responsibilities extend to all stockholders – and to act accordingly. You should not continue to “go with the flow” and rubberstamp
Given Dr. Farokhzad’s track record of value destruction and the hopelessly conflicted members of the Board, we are calling for you to act now for the benefit of all stockholders. We would urge the Board to immediately publicly announce a sale process. If there is any discussion about using Seer’s cash to fund new acquisitions, we would urge you to immediately resign and publicly state your disagreement with the Company. Lastly, we’d remind you that you can and will be held liable for the decisions you make as a fiduciary at Seer.
We believe the Company can be sold in the near term at a substantial premium to the current share price. We look forward to Seer publicly announcing a sale process led by a reputable advisor.
Sincerely,
| _________________________ |
|
1 The Company’s Form 10-K filings. Cash burned in operations refers to the sum of net cash used in operating activities, purchases of property and equipment and proceeds from disposal of property and equipment in 2023, 2024 and 2025. |
|
2 The Company’s Q4 and full-year 2025 earnings release dated |
|
3 Change in the Company’s closing share price from |
|
4 Market capitalization as of |
|
5 The Company’s press release and Form 8-K dated |
|
6 Complaint filed by |
|
7
Schedule 13G filed on |
|
8 Company Form 10-Q filings. |
|
9 The Company’s Form 10-K dated |
|
10 The Company’s investor relations website states that |
|
11 The Company’s Form 10-K filings. |
|
12 Company Form 4 filing dated |
|
13 FactSet, Seer share price change from |
|
14 FactSet, Senti BioSciences, Inc. share price change from |
|
15 Pfizer and BIND press release dated |
|
16 As detailed in Mr. Taylor’s lawsuit, |
View source version on businesswire.com: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260304714065/en/
greg@fondrenlp.com
Source: On Behalf of