Studies Show Proposed City Takeover of TEP is Infeasible
-
A
City of Tucson takeover of Tucson Electric Power’s local grid would cost city taxpayers more than$4 billion and increase electric bills in the city by$5.8 billion over 20 years, according to an independent analysis commissioned by TEP. - The risky, expensive proposal would threaten reliability, reduce available funding for clean energy investments, compromise economic development, and create significant new financial challenges for the city.
- Most residents are very satisfied with TEP and the reliability of its service, according to an independent survey commissioned by TEP.
It would cost the city more than
The additional cost of service from a city-run utility would escalate over time, from an extra
“These latest findings reaffirm what we have consistently stated: A government takeover of our system would be an unrealistic, unaffordable, and unnecessary distraction,” said TEP CEO
“Pursuing this course would place an enormous financial burden on
Steep Unnecessary Costs
The
For example, that study assumed a municipal utility could begin operating in
The Brattle Group’s study highlights other critical factors that affected the conclusion reached by GDS Associates’ and Best Best & Krieger’s study regarding the financial feasibility of municipalization in the city:
- That study assumes a constant average increase in TEP’s future electricity rates based, at least in part, on historical inflation. Because this was calculated during a period when inflation was at its highest in the past 40 years, it overstates the rates against which the estimated rates of the municipal utility are compared.
- One scenario in that study assumes acquisition of TEP’s assets at net book value. This unrealistic assumption is inconsistent with recent precedent and serves to artificially reduce the projected rates of a municipal utility.
“These omissions create the false impression that a takeover is financially achievable,” Gray said. “In fact, the city would be taking on billions in new debt in an attempt to duplicate the critical services that TEP already provides efficiently across the region.”
An Unrealistic Option
Activists urging the city to start a municipal electric utility often highlight the success of public power providers that have been operating for decades. But more recent efforts to municipalize privately owned systems have been much less successful.
Reduced Efficiency, Greater Risk
Beyond whether a municipal utility would be financially feasible,
- the time and resources necessary to undertake the municipalization process;
- whether the City has expertise in providing safe, reliable and efficient electric service, and
- the potential for acquisition or other related costs to increase as more detailed studies are completed to support separation of the new municipal utility from the remaining TEP system.
Seizing TEP’s assets would force city residents to assume full responsibility for a municipal utility’s debt, cost overruns and legal liabilities, risks that are currently shared by the company. That transition also would deprive residents of the strong, transparent, independent oversight currently provided by the
“Pursuing this course of action would put our community’s energy future at risk,” Gray said. “A forced takeover would jeopardize reliability, slow clean energy development, and create roadblocks for economic development initiatives that depend on TEP’s proven ability to deliver power safely, reliably, and sustainably.”
Local Residents Support TEP
Despite a push for municipalization by some activists, most local residents are happy with TEP and its service, according to a recent survey conducted for TEP by
The survey of 500 local residents, including 245
- 81 percent of local residents are highly satisfied with TEP. 52 percent rated the company as 9 or 10 on a scale of 1-10, while another 29 percent offered a rating of 7 or 8.
- More than 90 percent of residents are highly satisfied with the reliability of TEP’s service, with more than 70 percent giving it a 9 or 10 rating on a scale of 1 to 10.
“The activists who have been trying to drum up support for a city takeover don’t reflect the perspective of our larger community,” Gray said. “I think most people want to see TEP and the
TEP has collaborated with the city in support of its energy objectives, including the sustainability goals in its Climate Action and Adaptation Plan. One example: Since last year, TEP has been providing the city with 100 percent renewable power for its municipal operations through a clean energy supply program approved by the
“We’re hopeful that the city will set aside any further consideration of a TEP takeover so we can focus on collaborating to support a strong economy and high quality of life in our community,” Gray said.
TEP provides safe, reliable electric service to 457,000 customers in
TEP and its parent company,
View source version on businesswire.com: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260224238669/en/
News Media Contact:
(520) 884-3725
jbarrios@tep.com
Source: